Around one in five Australians will develop an alcohol use disorder, such as dependence, during their lifetime.
While some people will seek treatment for problem drinking, more than half of patients who go through inpatient withdrawal treatment, or detox, relapse within two weeks of discharge.
My team and I have found a new form of brain training can have positive results for people going through detox.
The conscious brain versus the subconscious brain
When we want to change a behavior like alcohol use, we might use our conscious brain to think about the benefits quitting will bring, such as improved sleep and being sharper in the mornings. We might reflect on the downsides if we continue to drink, like the unwanted calories, the cost, and the risk of harm to our physical or mental health.
But despite these conscious thought processes, we still may find ourselves reaching into the fridge for a beer, or pouring a glass of wine, as though on “autopilot”. This is because our subconscious brain is in action, driving the desire to drink alcohol.
Over time, when we drink frequently, alcohol cues such as places, sights, smells, and social situations that remind us of drinking subconsciously capture our attention and drive impulses to drink. This tendency is called cognitive bias.
In Australia, we’re continually bombarded with alcohol cues, whether from bottle shops, pubs, or advertising. Recent research found we’re targeted by an alcohol advertisement as often as every 35 seconds on social media.
But by reducing cognitive bias towards alcohol cues, we can increase the likelihood our behavior will be driven by our conscious rather than our subconscious brain.
Training our subconscious brain
A relatively new form of brain training that directly targets cognitive biases is showing promising results in treating alcohol use disorders.
Cognitive bias modification is a computerized brain-training program that trains people to repeatedly “avoid” alcohol-related cues, and to “approach” neutral or positive ones.
Using a joystick, the user repeatedly pushes away pictures of alcohol, and pulls healthier alternatives, such as bottled water, towards them. By practicing this over and over again, the avoidance of alcohol cues becomes automatic, thereby disabling the autopilot response to these cues.
Cognitive bias modification is delivered in several residential rehabilitation facilities in Germany, where it’s recommended in treatment guidelines.
It’s not yet available in Australia.
What we did
Our study, published today in JAMA Psychiatry, was a randomized control trial with 300 patients from four alcohol withdrawal units in Melbourne.
Roughly half were allocated to the intervention group, to receive one 15-minute session of cognitive bias modification a day for four consecutive days during their week-long detox treatment. The other half were allocated to a control group and received a pretend version of the training.
Before the treatment, participants generally had an automatic tendency to approach alcohol cues with the joystick. But we found the cognitive bias modification generally shifted this to an automatic tendency to avoid them.
Most importantly, cognitive bias modification increased rates of abstinence by 17% at two weeks after discharge. Some 63.8% of the brain-training group reported no alcohol use, compared with 46.8% of the control group.
The main limitation of our study was that alcohol use after treatment was self-reported. The vast geographical catchment of the withdrawal units meant we had to do follow-up interviews over the phone, so we couldn’t use tools like breathalyzers or blood tests to verify abstinence.
Nonetheless, we feel confident cognitive bias modification can optimize outcomes for patients receiving treatment for alcohol addiction. The training is simple, safe, easy to implement, and cost-effective, and we believe it should be routinely offered as part of inpatient withdrawal treatment in Australia.
Now we’re trialling an app version
Inpatient treatment services are geared towards people with moderate to severe alcohol use disorders. But these people represent only a fraction of those who want to reduce or stop drinking.
Recognizing this, we’ve developed a smartphone version of cognitive bias modification called SWiPE. It enables users to personalize their training by selecting alcoholic beverages or brands they wish to avoid.
At the same time, the app aims to strengthen motivation for quitting or reducing alcohol use by training users to repeatedly swipe towards meaningful, goal-related images they select from their photo libraries (for example, of family, friends, hobbies, travel, and so on).
We’re currently running a trial to test whether SWiPE effectively reduces alcohol consumption and craving. Early results, not yet peer-reviewed or published, are encouraging.
In today’s culture where we make instantaneous decisions with the swipe of a finger, if it proves to be effective, this app could be adapted to weaken the subconscious drivers of other unhealthy habits we wish to break, such as smoking and the overconsumption of unhealthy foods.
Images used courtesy of Pexels/Pressmaster